Archive

Archive for the ‘Everything Else’ Category

Moving to drlongnecker.com!

September 19, 2012 Comments off

I’m finally taking the time to replace the domain redirect and house my blog, prototype site, and other fun toys over at http://drlongnecker.com.

This WordPress blog will remain for link joy and the information it contains (rather than export/import madness).

Stop by, say hi, and look forward to new posts coming soon!

-david

Categories: Everything Else

New Adventures Await with @Tracky!

After over a decade with the Wichita Public Schools, I’m starting a new adventure with fantastic folks at Tracky. I’m looking forward to the journey and opportunity to work with and learn from a fantastic team.

Onward!

Tracky - The Open Social Collaboration Platform

Categories: Everything Else, Workplace Tags: ,

Review: Asus Transformer TF-101

tl;dr: Awesome!

I wanted to give my review after at least a week to settle in and integrate into my daily ‘flow’.

Why the Asus Transformer?

I’ve looked at more tablets than I can remember, teetering between the Motorola Xoom, Apple iPad2, Notion Ink Adam, and the Transformer.  All of these seemed like great devices and had their own pros; however, the Transformer sold me on a few of its flashy innovations:

  • Asus seems dedicated to constant updates. They’ve already pushed out Android Honeycomb 3.1 OTA and it updated like a champ.
  • The docking station/keyboard is brilliant and really bridges the gap between netbook and tablet and adds incredible battery life.
  • The mix of hardware performance for an incredible price point (499$US for the 32GB unit and 149$US for the keyboard/docking station at Amazon.com).
  • Flash support. Yes, I’m looking at you iPad2.

Photo of the Transformer... and swanky placemat backdrop.

 

How has the Transformer changed things?

I’ve noticed it’s changed things in the oddest of ways. I haven’t opened my personal laptop since I got the Transformer (it looks big and powerful, but it’s just old and … well, old).

Around the house, I’ve found myself using the Transformer in place of my EVO. I use it in the kitchen to look up recipes, check for coupons, make note of my groceries in Mighty Shopper, and listen to music. Other times, like for this post, for simple word processing, web browsing, and email. More functionality and less squinting.

Work Computer Size ComparisonAt work, I’ve used Polaris Office for note taking, presentations (via the HDMI out), web browsing and research as I wander around the office with folks, and email. The remote desktop client (2X Client) allows me to remote into servers, my office desktop, and client machines for diagnostic work.

With Android 3.1, the web browser engine finally supports NTLM/Windows authentication so I can log into our corporate web sites (I hope this is coming to the Gingerbread builds soon).

I still have my phone with me through all this.. the Transformer hasn’t replaced the portability and features of my phone, but augmented what I can do without an actual desktop computer.

 

The Hardware

You can read the unit’s specifications, so I won’t drive into them too much. There are a few things to mention.

The bulk

Overall, the unit (and keyboard doc) are quite light compared to a normal 14" laptop.  The tablet itself is very comfortable to carry around (long days here at work, so I’ve been pacing around while researching on the web).

The keyboard dock

Image of the the keyboard dock.I was a bit worried that the keyboard dock would be uncomfortable to use; however, that’s not the case.  The keys are well spaced apart (once you get used to the ‘special’ keys at the top–I keep accidently locking the unit when I hit backspace) and the monitor can tilt back far enough for easy reading.

It’s important to note that the keyboard dock’s additional battery life is due to the dock charging the main unit while it’s docked.  This is advantageous.  Wander around and run the battery down a bit on the tablet, then dock and let the keyboard charge things up, detach, and you have a fully charged tablet again.

The POWER!

It is quite disappointing that the Transformer has a unique USB cable; however, even more so that it’s only about a meter long.  This hassle is aggravated by the fact you cannot charge the unit via USB while it’s on, so if you need a charge AND need to use it, you’re trapped a meter from your electrical connection or extension cord.

Thankfully, with the 14-16 hours of battery life, charging isn’t a central focus of the day (unlike my EVO which is dead by the time I get to work).

The video output

Less of a big deal and more of a ‘oh’ moment when digging for cables.  My EVO and a few other video devices all use micro HDMI so I had to pickup a 1.3a mini HDMI cable for the Transformer.

The screen

I love the screen. It’s a bit hard to see in high light (it’s not a Kindle for outdoor reading); however, the fingerprints are a bit out of control. I plan on getting a screen protector which, I hope, will help.

The camera

The camera is only a 5MP (compared to the 8MP in my EVO) and takes 4:3 photos rather than wide screen. That aside, it’s quite a good camera for general ‘here I am!’ sorts of photos–like lounging on the hammock in the back yard on a peaceful evening.

Example Transformer camera image--my back yard.

The lack of right click

I understand… I really do. The Android device doesn’t have a context for ‘right-click’; however, I dream of the day when it does so that the remote desktop clients have right-click.

Keeping it safe

I picked up a Belkin 10" Netbook Sleeve when ordering and highly recommend it as a carry case for the Transformer.  The unit, whether you’re just carrying the tablet or the tablet and keyboard dock, fit very well into the sleeve and the zips/material feel and look good.

 

The Software

Out of the box, the Transformer walks you through a simple configuration–much like my EVO (or any Android phone). Setting up email, syncing contacts, and such worked just fine. I was impressed that the unit also synced my Google bookmarks. That’s an added bonus.

The basics are included:

  • Email (Enterprise, Gmail, etc.) – The layout and flow of both mail applications is the same and works VERY well on landscape mode.
  • Calendaring – nice, clean "Outlook-esque" layout.
  • Contacts – standard Android contacts client.
  • Polaris Office – bundled Office client for DOC, XLS, and PPT. Works quite well (and what I used for this post). It can also read/write to Google Docs, Dropbox, and a few other cloud services. At this time, I’m getting 400 errors trying to save BACK to Google Docs; however, from the forums, it appears that it is a Google API issue.
  • MyReader – Simple eBook/pdf reader akin to Aikido.
  • MyNet – network-based HD streaming client. Detects my PlayOn devices and streams perfectly.
  • MyCloud – a subscription-based, unlimited storage system for music and files. Transformer includes a free 1 year subscription. I haven’t dug into this much as I have LiveSync and DropBox.

In addition to the boxed software, there are a few applications that I’d recommend (and seem to work quite well with the Transformer and Honeycomb):

  • Dolphin Browser HD – Bit cleaner interface for web browsing and plugin modules (3.1 addresses some rendering issues though).

    .

  • Amazon Kindle Reader – Great for reading Kindle books on the run (and without your Kindle). The update for Android 3.1 works even better!
  • Pandora – Great and solid music client.
  • Grooveshark – Formatting is a bit off, but works fantastic to query and stream your favorite tunes.
  • Google Reader – Great tablet support for full-screen reading.
  • imo Chat beta – Best IM client I’ve found for any type of Android device.
  • Plume – best Twitter client that takes advantage of the notifications and wide screen layout.
  • DropBox – the Android DropBox client is pretty stellar.
  • PrintBot – a free (and for cheap) application to print to network devices over WIFI. Works great and, hopefully, future versions will allow for multiple printers.
    NOTE: Similar to the Gingerbread break, Netflix is defunct on Honeycomb as well. I had hopes (dreams) that 3.1 would fix it, but alas it doesn’t seem so. Netflix is adamant that a new version is in the works. I hope so. It was great to have mobile movies on my cell phone and the Transformer seems ideal

Upgrading to Android Honeycomb 3.1

honeycomb_3-1-580x309On 10 June 2011, Asus released Android Honeycomb 3.1 for the Transformer. The official version is v8.4.4.5 (the SKUs are separate by locale). 

There are two options:

I’m impatient, so I opted for the manual method.  The process was quite simple:

  1. Download the 8.4.4.5 zip file from the internet.
  2. On a microSD card create an \asus\update directory and copy the ZIP file into that directory.
  3. Insert the microSD card into the Transformer. You should see a notification that an update is available.
  4. The device will reboot a few times and then be good to go.

There are a few highlights to 3.1 (detailed by the release notes) that I really dig:

  1. The browser (and any browsers relying on it’s webkit) now supports NTLM/Windows Authentication. AWESOME for work!
  2. (Most) widgets are now resizable. I’ve come across a few that won’t resize.
  3. Speed! 3.1 generally feels faster.  Multitasking across a dozen apps with notifications flying and music playing doesn’t seem to bother it.

Summary

With the tablet upgraded to 3.1, the applications that I like, and features that keep impressing me, I think the Transformer will continue to be a great fit. The keyboard matches my dire need to rapidly input information (take notes, respond to emails) and the portability matches my recent need to roam free of wires and surf the web. 

The Transformer is a fantastic bridge between the smallest of laptops and the largest of cell phones and, unfortunately, is what I’d hoped the Google Chromebook would have been.  Don’t get me wrong, I like my Chromebook–it was free and I like free–but the Android-based Transformer can actually DO the things I need to do in my day-to-day life.

Cr-48 : The First Twenty Four

December 18, 2010 7 comments
I was shocked to see the Cr-48 sitting out on the front porch last night.  I tend to pre-order things and forget–so I figured that’d it’d happened again.  Instead, Silicon Valley Santa came early. Apparently the first group of testers weren’t notified as they wanted to see how wacky we went on the web. I’m a good little lemming–hence the blog post. 🙂 

After a full day of use, I wanted to join the thousands blogging about the Cr-48 and jot down some of my impressions–how it worked, what DID work, and what didn’t work. I’ve made an effort to do most everything on the Cr-48 today–including this blog post. Man, I miss Live Writer. 😛

Unboxing and Initial Setup

Out of the box, the machine just ‘starts’.  Fantastic. That’s how unboxing a new device should be. Unfortunately, I hit a brick wall immediately after. My network is locked down pretty tight and one of those security measures only allows authorized MAC addresses to attempt to authenticate.

“How the heck do I get the MAC address on this thing?”

It wasn’t on the screen, so I looked all over the unit. Nothing. Yanked the battery… nothing. Seriously?

DIDN’T WORK: There needs to be a way to spit out the network ifconfig information on startup. If the device is appealing to geeks, then give the geeks some love.

After hacking my own network, resetting the security schema, logging in, and resetting it, I was golden. The out-of-box-experience (OOBE) for the Cr-48 is actually a lot better than most the netbooks I’ve worked with if nothing else for it’s single ‘environment/task’ configuration. I guess that’s both a pro and con of having low expectations for the device (e.g. I don’t expect it to be it more than a glorified web browser).

WORKS: Instant update to the new version of ChromeOS, restart, sync everything, and ready-to-go perfection.

DIDN’T WORK: When the Cr-48 asks to take your picture, do it–even if you just hold up something or take a photo of empty air. Why?  Because ChromeOS doesn’t have a mechanism built in to MODIFY the photo afterwards if the initial picture wasn’t taken. You have to totally format and restart if you want to have a snazzy photo.

Rooting to Developer Mode

Now that I’m logged in and see my data, I want power. *insert evil laugh here*

Thankfully, swapping to developer mode is a FEATURE of the system.  You can’t do it ala software, it’s a physical switch near the battery. The only thing I don’t like is the sad computer screen when you start.  Seriously Google? My computer doesn’t need to be sad, it needs to have a magic wand or a hoverboard when it’s in root mode.

As the instructions explain, you should do this immediately as it wipes user partition (takes a few minutes). After that, you’re good to go.

At this point, you can swap to console windows just like a regular Linux device. Hit up VT2 by hitting Ctrl-Alt- -> (the forward button at the top, like where F2 would be). Log in and hack away or, as the prompt says, “have fun and send patches!”

NOTE: Hit Ctrl-Alt- Speaker Mute Button (LOL). It takes you to the console where the kernel messages are being spewed out. Interesting if you’re a bit geeky.

WORKS: Empowering users who WANT to root the unit is fantastic. I didn’t have to stand on one hand to control my device.

Using the Device

It’s hard to not like the package.  It’s a bit plain, but that’s expected for a prototype device created on a budget (they sent out ~60k of these for free… I’m sure Silicon Valley Santa’s elves made it ‘good enough’).

Screen: The 12.1” screen is crazy bright on full brightness. A couple of notches down from max is fine in a bright room. It’s clear and clean as well. Nice.

Keyboard: I actually love the keyboard. The search button in place of CAPS lock is brillant. When does anyone actually USE CAPS lock these days (except for the trolls on forum posts)? The search button doubles as a ‘new window’ when you think about it which really speeds up navigation once you get used to it.

Touchpad: No, this is a touchbad. I hope the real units either fix this or do away with it. Want to right click in Google Docs and fix your typos? Not a chance. Right-click is a mythical beast that only works when you don’t want it to. Have larger, warm hands (me!)? You’ll be rocketing your cursor all around the screen while you type. Know where to ‘click’? I sure didn’t. There’s no clue that the bottom of the pad is the buttons. I guess MacBooks are the same way–maybe this is a PC user snafu. For now, this is easily solved by a itty bitty Targus mouse I use for traveling.

DIDN’T WORK: The touchbad gets a DIDN’T WORK all of it’s own.

Sound: I have Pandora constantly running (ala Extension) and it’s not too bad. This bad boy isn’t running Bose or Klipsch, but it’s good enough for sitting and surfing. The headphone port has a nice range, no background static (which my Dell laptop is notorious for having).

Battery: Since my last ‘plug-in’, which was about 5 hours ago, the meter says I have 1:23 hours left on the clock. That includes having a USB mouse plugged in, 6 polling tabs open, Pandora constantly playing, and writing this post in Google Docs.  So if things go to plan, the life will be about 6.5 hours. For netbooks, that’s not unheard of; however, l’m sure having the monitor a bit brighter, streaming music, and having HootSuite, Mail, StackOverflow, Groups, Reader, Docs, and four search tabs all running for that time is a bit more than a normal netbook operates with. It’s far more than my normal laptop would survive–and it has two high capacity batteries.

Performance: Honestly? Considering it’s the backbone of the entire system, It’s kinda slow.  Considering it’s running a 1.66GHz Atom, has 2GB of memory, and an SSD hard drive, it FEELS slow–which is really all that matters.  Opening a tab shouldn’t take a few seconds. Page rendering on Amazon.com shouldn’t load one little image at a time.

I’m wondering if that’s because the AR928X card is stuck in 802.11g mode instead of 802.11n mode (Google search is filled with posts about the cards not kicking up to N-mode on Linux). Hopefully this will be addressed in time with patches.

WORKS: For normal operation, once you get used to the flow of the device, isn’t not bad though. Learning the keyboard commands is REQUIRED–if you’re a mouser, even with an external mouse, you’re going to weep at how slow it can be to get around.

UX: Using the Cr-48

The user experience of the device is … different. There’s no other way to put it. That’s not a bad thing either. I spend a majority of my computer time either coding, gaming, or “all other tasks”. I still have my desktop for coding (VS2010 brings my powerhouse computer to it’s knees–I have no expectations a mobile device could run it) and gaming; however, this little computer fits the “all other tasks” category well.

To do that, however, requires a bit of change. Here are a few of the things I’ve discovered to help me use the Cr-48.

Do not try to use tabs for everything. Using tabs is great–we love tab-based browsing, but think outside that. Remember that you can open new windows (Ctrl-N). Think of these new windows as multiple ‘desktops’. For example, I’m running Google Docs in one, my standard ‘browsing’ in another, and my ‘communication’ apps (HootSuite, Mail, Groups, Reader) in another. It allows me to easily Alt-Tab between work environments while still keeping each separate.

Become a keyboard junkie. Press Ctrl-Alt-/ on the keyboard to pop up a SWEET interactive keyboard map (every app should have this).  These are the keys for the ChromeOS. On top of that, learn the keyboard shortcuts of Mail, Groups, Reader, your twitter application, whatever other site you use (e.g. github.com has some pretty slick keyboard shortcuts to move around their site totally mouseless). This really speeds things up.

Some good ChromeOS keys to get started:

  • Alt-Up/Alt-Down : Page Up/Page Down
  • Alt-Tab : Switch between windows
  • Ctrl-Tab : Switch between tabs
  • Alt-D : Focus on Location bar (and select so you can start typing)
  • Alt-Backspace : Delete

Remember the built-in hard keys. Since the Cr-48 is missing function (F-key) keys, it has a row of hard keys built-in. Back, forward, refresh, full screen, swap window, brightness, and sound controls right at your fingertips (literally if you’re hands are on home row). Full screen and back/forward are pretty snazzy once you get used to them there.

Find the app or extension that fits your requirements. I’ll talk more about extensions and apps here in a moment; however, use the Chrome Web Store and explore. There are a few cases where your application may offer BOTH an extension and app. Try both. One may work better than the other for your use.

Extensions

Since the launch of the Chrome Web Store, there’s been a lot of discussion about what an extension is… and what an app is… and why we shouldn’t all just use bookmarks like we have been.

Since ChromeOS syncs to your Chrome profile, anything you already sync shows up automatically. I had my Goo.gl Shortener, Web Developer, Mail, Evernote, glee, and Pandora extensions right OOBE.

DIDN’T WORK: The only extension that’s been a bit wonky has been glee.  It doesn’t seem to properly detect input areas–so pressing the gleeKey (‘g’) at any time pops up the box. Bummer ‘cause glee would be rockin’ on a netbook considering how keyboard-oriented it is.

WORKS: This is more of a recommendation than a works, but still. If you use Pandora, use the extension, not the app. Why? Because the Pandora app just loads up pandora.com. On a normal computer, that’s fine, but this is a Linux-based platform. What happens when Flash starts up on a Linux-based platform? Kittens are killed. The app also requires a full tab to operate while the extension sits happily in the extension bar, blaring your tunes.

Apps

I’ll admit, my initial response to the Chrome Web apps was “wut”? Why would I want fancy bookmarks? With the Cr-48, that’s still pretty much the case. There are a few apps which seem to run as actual applications, like TweetDeck’s ChromeDeck. Everything else seems to just be a bookmark to a site. That is a huge bummer. I’m hoping as the Cr-48 and other ChromeOS systems are released that this changes.

An example. As I discussed above, the Pandora application is tragic. It loads Pandora.com which promptly dies due to Flash.  The extension is rockin’, but there’s room for improvement.  ChromeOS supports panels (little pop-ups at the bottom of the screen). That’d be a great place for some Pandora action.

Random Thoughts

Multimedia is sorta meh. Flash sucks on here. I expect that on a Linux device, but I’d assume the owners of YouTube would have worked out SOMETHING magical. No, sir.  That means poor performance for YouTube and Hulu and, well, 90% of the rest of the web. Unfortunately, since this is a Linux box, Silverlight doesn’t natively work either (I haven’t tried installing Moonlight yet… though I don’t have high hopes). That counts out Netflix. It’s a bit of a letdown because the Atom processors are toted for being able to do multimedia on-the-go. I honestly think this machine COULD do it if it wasn’t for the Flash/Silverlight limitation on Linux and that really hurts to say.

WORKS: For some reason, the Flash player (using FlowPlayer) on Tekpub.com is BRILLANT and works like a champ. I don’t know enough about how the compression/streaming/playback works on FlowPlayer to say why–though it’s something I’m going to look into for a few sites I have using Flash movies.

The window switching animation is confusing. Okay, I’ll accept that I may be dense, but it just doesn’t feel natural. Rather than looping left-to-right through your windows, when you get to the end, you slingshot back to the first… so if you have three, you see left-left-right-left-left-right. That’s fine once you get used to it, but the right (the one that’s going from last to first) LOOKS like it’s going BACK. Just an odd UX thing.

Mounting storage is… awkward. I’m assuming this is a prototype issue and won’t affect the production devices, but the device is SO LOCKED DOWN that using the SD card slot is a real pain. I’m thinking this is to encourage cloud storage, which is fine, but if that’s the case, why is the SD card slot there? I can download files in Chrome, but moving them onto the removable device requires some magic.

But I want something from {device}… For this article, figuring out how the heck to get photos on here was a REAL pain. I have a phone that can take snazzy widescreen photos, but getting them to the web is a bit of a pain outside of TwitPic. I have a Sony digital camera, but plugging it into the USB port on here was futile. I wasn’t going to swap the front web cam around to snap photos–that was just silly. So how can a blogger use this and attach photos? I’m still working that out–note the lack of photos in this stream of text post.

Give us a right-click keyboard button! If right-clicking is going to be such a pain, give us the ‘properties’ right-click key that we’ve gotten used to on Windows keyboards for so long. I’ve REALLY been missing that (especially while typing this post to fix typos–I guess I should be less lazy and spell the words right the first time).

That’s it for the first twenty-four hours and see, all this cloud computing talk and I haven’t once said “to the cloud!”… oh, damn.

Stop using MS Paint for your demos – Get Balsamiq Mocks!

November 25, 2009 3 comments

Ever had your boss walk in and want a ‘mockup’ of a product the next day? In the past, I’d whip something up either in Visio (*cough* or Paint *cough*) and give a basic sketch of how screens and flow would work.

Over the past year, I’ve read a lot of rave reviews around Balsamiq Mockups, but hadn’t had a chance to try it out. 

I emailed Balsamiq to inquery how their licensing structure worked.  I was interested in purchasing a personal copy (budgets are tight here at the office—cuts in public education are running deep) and curious if I could still use it for “work-related” activities. To my surprise, I had nearly an instant response thanking me for my interest and providing me a free license to use here at work (educational). That’s freaking AWESOME and greatly appreciated and further motivates me to pick up a copy to use for consulting and personal projects.

So, next comes usage.  Up until now, I’ve tinkered with the ‘web demo’ version of Balsamiq. I was pleased that, on moving to the desktop version, the layout, tools, and functionality remained almost identical. No lost time or learning curve.

How It Saved The Day

Last week, I was hit up by the opening situation.  “Hey, we need a demo of how you’d do this… and we need it later this afternoon to present to the laywers, {big boss A}, and {big boss B}…”

For something to hit that level, I’d usually opt to bypass the Big Chief and Crayon as well as Paint and simply mock up a UI on the web.  Unfortunately, for this, the time wasn’t there; however, Balsamiq was up to the task.

Rough (very rough) specs to screens, screens transformed into flow, and added into a PowerPoint for a quick presentation, acceptance by all parties involved, and hero fanfare.  We’re now a week later and using those mockups to generate our UI screens—and the customer loves how well things translate without any ‘surprises’. Excellent.

UPDATE: I just pulled down the 1.6.46 version of Balsamiq and it exports to PDF. Sweet..

Features I Love

Linked Screens – A bit of a counter to one of the ‘Things I Wish It Did’ is the ability to link mockup screens together with ‘links’.  It’s great for demos to provide a true flow of how things fit together.

In this example, we’re showing a simulation of the login screen. You can see the ‘link’ icon on the Login button. In a demo, clicking the Login button takes us to our next screen—just like it would (if authenticated right ;)) in our app.

Balsamiq Mockups - Linked Screens

Sticky Notes – On a few screens, showing business logic is a bit challenging. That’s where I love sticky notes comments. I’m a huge fan of whiteboarding and sticky notes and am thrilled I can bring that into my mocks. It’s also great when exporting and being able to keep track of comments and ideas as the team is working through a mock.

Balsamiq Mockups - Sticky Notes

Easily Populated Controls – Data grids, buttons, tabs—the common elements of a user interface and all easily populated with test data.  No longer do I need to draw lines in Paint or try to copy/paste screen clips out of Excel to get a decent looking grid view—a bit of text and commas and a snazzy grid appears!

Balsamiq Mockups - Grid

Things I Wish It Did

Master Pages – Most UI layouts have the same headers/footers. You can easily reproduce this by ‘cloning’ the current mockup; however, when the customer walks in and wants to move the logo from the left side to the right side, you now have 10… 20… 100 individual screens to move it on. I’d love to be able to designate a screen as the ‘parent’.

… wow, that’s about all I can come up with!

Comic Sans Makes Me Cry… and How to Fix it

One thing that really threw me about Mockups was the fact that it used Comic Sans. Seriously? Thankfully, I’m not the first to ask this and they’ve provided a stellar walkthrough on how to use whatever font you desire.

My configuration file looks like:

<config>
 <fontFace>Segoe UI</fontFace>
 <rememberWindowSize>true</rememberWindowSize>
 <useCookies>true</useCookies>
</config>

I opted for Vista/Windows 7’s clean Segoe UI font.  Having my mockups look like my scribbles on paper wasn’t that important to me.  Professional earns more points than crayons on a Big Chief tablet. 😉

Conclusions

I’ve found myself, since picking up Balsamiq Mockups, simply using it for everything.  Sitting in planning meetings and sketching out reports, screens, even data flows.  With a little creativity, you can sketch out almost anything.  For the things you can’t, I’m ‘crayoning’ it using my Bamboo tablet and drawing out what I want–then importing it as an image. Sweet.

If you haven’t check out Balsamiq, give it a run–it’s an amazing tool.

 

Comparing Google and Bing

June 1, 2009 Comments off

Bing, the latest iteration of Windows Live Search, is now available for use and has been getting quite a few rave reviews.  Miguel Carrasco wrote a lengthy post discussing the benefits of Bing over Google; however, maybe I’m old fashioned, but I see a lot of the hype as overhead.

Not to nitpick, but searching DIRECTLY for product names will return advertisements and sponsored sales information—no matter the search engine.  Miguel’s post (searching for a Nikon D60 camera).  Using my new fanboy item, the Palm Pre, as an example, I can see that the Google page actually has FEWER (real estate) “advertisements” than the Bing search.

Bing has a whopping 6 sponsored links… along with something called Bing cashback that I haven’t really read up on yet.  That along witht he lost space on the left seems like a lot of waste.

Bing

Google drops off a bit of space for the 3 sponsored links, but keeps it thin and uses it’s integration with YouTube to show previews and group the video results to the top.

BUT… how much does that matter?  If Google’s page takes a moment more to load, do the background graphics, fancy headers, and AJAX postbacks on the Bing page make up that difference?

“Previews” in Google and Bing

An exciting point with Bing is the content previews.  Hover over a search result and it provides a bit more information.  This, however, has been in Google’s search for quite a while if you turn on the functionality.

I’ll admit, I like the hover effect.  Clean, renders relatively quickly (noticed a bit of delay on some pages, but not too bad), and seems to parse content well.  But is it ground breaking?  Nah, not really.

Google’s had it for a while, though I’ll admit, I rarely use it (I used it more while doing heavy research in school).

The difference is that Google’s requires you to turn it on… For those who don’t use it, the dynamic filtering is FANTASTIC (and provides that handy “left side bar” that Bing is raving about).  Remember—Google was originally focused on extremely streamlined results—”more text” and AJAX postbacks would be considered evil. 😉

If you really do need more images, using Google’s “Images on the page” provides a cool look at what graphics are on the page.

Are product searches always what we do?  Nah!

How often do we actually search for a product name—especially in the workplace?  When I’m looking for my Pre, sure, but 90% of the day is spent searching for error messages, code snippets, and forum messages.  Face it, I JFGI it all day long. I encourage coworkers to JFGI. Etc.

So how does Bing and Google stack up when searching for a less commercial, more technical request?  I’ve recently dug into db40 and needed to dig up some ideas for id generation.  I remember reading a blog post recently about it, but couldn’t remember who wrote it.

Bing returned an interesting result set… but didn’t turn up (in the first 10) what I was looking for…

Nearly all of the results were root domains or directories—nothing real specific (blog posts, forum posts, etc) from the titles.  Since the cool Bing “sorting and grouping” doesn’t appear to apply to everything quiet yet (not sure if that’s context-based or a newness/lack of indexing), I was left with “all results”.

On the other hand, Google appears to put more priority on the title of the page.  Notice on the Bing search results, “Id Generation” didn’t appear in ANY of the page titles whereas they’re in all of the titles of the Google results.

The title doesn’t mean these are the BEST results; however, with news stories, blog posts, etc—the takeaway point will usually be in the title. 

The blog post I was wanting showed up second in the Google results.  The Bing results referenced Tuna’s blog a few places; however, didn’t actually reference the post for “Id Generation in db4o”.  The one time it WAS mentioned (the 4th result of Bing), it was a stale link to the front page of Tuna’s blog—not the actual post.

Conclusion

The selling point to Google for many years now has been two fold:

1) Extremely clean, fast user interface
2) Reliable and relevant results

I moved away from AltaVista, Yahoo, and other engines years ago because they wanted to be ‘cute’ and while Bing has potential, it’s already too cute for my tastes without any real benefit.

It’ll be interesting to see how Bing grows—and how it affects Google.  It’s too early, however, to say that Bing is this saving grace—especially if you’ve never dug into all of the features of Google.

Cup Is Ready for Use!

May 11, 2009 Comments off

After a long and winding path from California to Kansas, the Cup that can hold any thing (of type T where T : IDrinkable) arrived.  An action shot below—brewing a strong cup of Timothy’s Midnight Magic Extra Bold.

Generic Cup of T

Yes, it’s very geeky, but it’s so cool.

Here’s how to get one:

1. Check out the original cup by odennison on Zazzle.com.

2. Customize!  (I opted for a two-tone navy mug at 15oz).

3. Ship!

The cup is very sturdy, no defects, and they’re running a 10% off sale.  I’m keeping that one at home, but have one on order to geek out here at the office too.  🙂  Beats the plastic cups I have to use now.

Categories: c#, Everything Else, Insanity!